2018-2024年全国医院感染相关医疗损害责任纠纷案件责任认定及赔偿概况

Liability determination and compensation of liability disputes involving medical damages related to hospital-associated infections in China from 2018 to 2024

  • 摘要:
    目的 剖析医院感染相关医疗损害责任纠纷案件的特征,明确医疗机构在感染防控中的法律风险。
    方法 通过检索“中国裁判文书网”2018年1月1日-2025年1月1日医院感染相关医疗损害民事判决书,筛检有效案件90件,运用描述性统计案件分布、过错行为、争议焦点及责任认定特征,Kruskal-Wallis H检验及Fisher精确检验各变量与赔偿金额的相关性。
    结果 涉案医院以三级医院为主,占比71.11%,最高赔偿金额为240.36万元,骨科(16.67%)为高发科室,手术部位感染(39.02%)占比最高;感染防控不足(36.27%)、诊疗规范执行不到位(30.39%)为主要过错行为;因果关系认定(51.37%)是核心争议焦点;医院承担≥50%责任的案件占47.78%,手术和是否接受重症监护室(ICU)治疗是医院感染医疗损害责任纠纷的限制高危因素(P < 0.05)。
    结论 研究发现三级医院、骨科手术、手术部位感染及ICU治疗是医院感染纠纷的高危因素。感染防控不足与诊疗不规范是主要过错,而因果关系的认定高度依赖证据链的完整性。研究结果为医疗机构强化感染防控、规范诊疗行为、降低医疗损害风险提供了重要参考依据。

     

    Abstract:
    OBJECTIVE To analyze the characteristics of liability disputes involving medical damages related to hospital-associated infections, and to elucidate the corresponding legal risks for healthcare institutions in infection prevention and control.
    METHODS By searching the "China Judgment Online" for civil judgments regarding medical damages related to hospital-associated infections from Jan. 1, 2018, to Jan. 1, 2025, 90 cases were enrolled. Descriptive statistics were adopted to analyze the distribution of cases, faulty behaviors, focus of disputes and characteristics of liability determination. The Kruskal-Wallis H test and Fisher′s exact test were employed to examine the correlation between corresponding variables and compensation amounts.
    RESULTS The hospitals involved were predominantly tertiary institutions (71.11%), with the highest compensation amount reaching RMB 2.4036 million. Orthopedics (16.67%) was identified as the department with the highest incidence of disputes, where surgical site infections accounted for the largest proportion of cases (39.02%). The primary faulty behaviors were inadequate infection prevention and control (36.27%) and non-compliance with diagnostic and treatment standards (30.39%), while the determination of causality (51.37%) emerged as the core point of dispute. In 47.78% of the cases, the hospital was held responsible for ≥50% of the liability. Furthermore, surgery and intensive care unit (ICU) admission were identified as significant risk factors associated with these disputes (P < 0.05).
    CONCLUSIONS This study identifies tertiary hospitals, orthopedic surgeries, surgical site infections and ICU admission as high-risk factors for disputes related to hospital-associated infections. Inadequate infection prevention and control and non-standardized diagnosis and treatment are the main faults, while the determination of causality highly relies on the integrity of the evidence chain. This research provides important reference for medical institutions to strengthen infection prevention and control, standardize diagnostic and treatment practices and reduce the risk of medical damages.

     

/

返回文章
返回