MALDI-TOF MS与16S rRNA/ITS基因测序技术在微生物污染溯源中的性能比较及其应用

Performances of MALDI-TOF MS and 16S rRNA/ITS gene sequencing in source tracking of microbial contamination and their application potentialities

  • 摘要: 目的 评估基质辅助激光解吸电离飞行时间质谱(MALDI-TOF MS)在医院及医药生产环境中微生物污染溯源中的鉴定效能,为其在感染暴发调查与质量控制中的应用提供依据。方法 采集6个洁净环境中的90株分离菌株,采用MALDI-TOF MS与16S rRNA/ITS基因测序进行平行鉴定; 以测序结果为金标准,通过BLAST比对、RAxML最大似然法构建系统发育树,并结合R语言vegan包进行蛋白图谱聚类分析,系统比较两种方法在门、属、种水平的鉴定一致性及偏差类型。结果 测序成功鉴定全部90株(87株细菌、3株真菌),涵盖5个门48个物种; MALDI-TOF MS整体鉴定率为57.78%(52/90),属水平准确率100.00%(52/52),种水平准确率73.08%(38/52),但真菌未成功鉴定。厚壁菌门鉴定成功率最高,其次是放线菌门与变形菌门。部分近缘菌种(Staphylococcus taiwanensis误判为Staphylococcus haemolyticus)及种内异质性菌株(Micrococcus luteus)存在误判或聚类错位,蛋白图谱在4 800~5 500 m/z区域出现交叉峰。结论 MALDI-TOF MS可实现属水平高精度、分钟级快速鉴定,适用于医院感染暴发中污染源的应急筛查; 但其种水平准确性受限于数据库覆盖度与蛋白表达异质性。建议结合16S rRNA/ITS测序构建本地化数据库,以提升在临床与工业环境中微生物溯源的可靠性与时效性。

     

    Abstract: OBJECTIVE To observe the efficiency of matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF MS) in differential identification of source tracking of microbial contamination in the hospital and pharmaceutical manufacturing environments so as to provide evidence for the infection outbreak survey and quality control. METHODS Totally 90 microbial isolates were collected from 6 clean environments and were parallelly identified by using MALDI-TOF MS and 16S rRNA/ITS gene sequencing. The sequencing result was set as the golden standard, the phylogenetic tree was constructed through BLAST and RAxML, the cluster analysis of protein profile was performed with R language vegan package. The consistency and deviation types of identification on the levels of phylum, genus and species were systematically compared between the two methods. RESULTS All of the 90 isolates (87 strains of bacteria, 3 strains of fungi) were successfully identified by sequencing, covering 48 species across 5 phyla. MALDI-TOF MS yielded an overall identification rate of 57.78% (52/90), with 100.00% of the accurate rate at the genus level, 73.08% at the species level, but it failed to identify any fungi. Firmicutes showed the highest identification rate, followed by Actinobacteria and Proteobacteria. Misidentifications or clustering bias occurred among closely related species (Staphylococcus taiwanensis misidentified as S. haemolyticus) and heterogeneous strains (Micrococcus luteus), with overlapping peaks observed in the protein spectra within the 4800 to 5 500 m/z range. CONCLUSIONS MALDI-TOF MS enables highly precise, minute-scale rapid identification at the genus level, making it suitable for emergent screening of contamination sources during hospital infection outbreaks. However, the accuracy of identification on the species level is limited by database coverage and protein expression heterogeneity. It is recommended to integrate 16S rRNA/ITS sequencing to establish localized databases, thereby enhancing the reliability and timeliness of microbial source tracking in clinical and industrial settings.

     

/

返回文章
返回